Assignment: How to Make a Poem out of a Blah Day

fallingletters

Okay, recently I was bored and depressed by the lack of sunshine while I was at work, and in between helping engineers and students with their writing, I wrote this, to redeem the day:

Begin by changing the title, so that the verb Make becomes Cut, something edgy and sharp to contrast with the soft grey of the sky behind the flurries as they fall to the parking lot tarmac and melt into puddles. Find one beautiful thing, like the shiny blue car or the dark-haired woman holding her brown coat closed against the cold. Imagine her destination, the cancer she will beat and the young man she will marry, whole futures you will never know. Return to your own office chair, twirling you from present to future as the desk alternately waves goodbye and hello. Shake crumbs out of your keyboard and see what words fall to join them: speculate, December, winter, winter, winter.

Okay, that is nice, but is it any less a poem than:

Begin by changing the title, so that the verb

Make becomes Cut, something edgy and sharp

to contrast with the soft grey of the sky

behind the flurries as they fall to the parking lot

tarmac and melt into puddles. Find one beautiful thing,

like the shiny blue car or the dark-haired woman

holding her brown coat closed against the cold.

Imagine her destination, the cancer

she will beat and the young man she will marry,

whole futures you will never know. Return to

your own office chair, twirling you from present

to future as the desk alternately waves goodbye

and hello. Shake crumbs out of your keyboard

and see what words fall to join them: speculate,

December,

winter,

winter,

winter…

They history of prose poetry as a subversive form suggests that this poem is probably not crazy and exploratory enough. The French poet Charles Baudelaire (1821-1867), who coined the term “modernity,” is one of the form’s great-grandfathers. He thought of it as a way to rebel against traditional formal uses of the line, which in that period of French poetry were very strict. He wrote:

“Who among us has not dreamt, in moments of ambition, of the miracle of a poetic prose, musical without rhythm and rhyme, supple and staccato enough to adapt to the lyrical stirrings of the soul, the undulations of dreams, and sudden leaps of consciousness.”            —Dedication of Le Spleen de Paris

More recent writers of prose poetry include Americans Walt Whitman, Gertrude Stein, Allen Ginsburg, Charles Simic and Mary Oliver, so it seems to have moved from the edges to the mainstream. A friend of mine recently attended a workshop on the lyric essay, so when I find out more about that, I may start trying that form too…

Meanwhile, out of a depressing morning, I got a little tiny piece of art. And that is another of the uses of poetry, in whatever form you write it.

Poem Made Out of Questions

Why, if trees arebluebottles grey, do we color them brown? Why, when the sea is green, do we color it blue? Why do whales, so lonely now, still sing? How is it possible that on the cold ocean floor there is lava flowing up and out, hot and fiery? Why do anvils love gravity so very much? How does a clock always know exactly what time it is, and why do its hands always use sign language to tell us? Where do fools fall in love and will someone give me a lift there? Has anyone ever been stranded like Gilligan on the Isles of Langerhans? Did they send a message in a bottle? Was the bottle blue like a bluebottle fly or green like Robin Hood’s hat? If whiskey from Scotland is Scotch, why isn’t whiskey from America Amertch? And if a very large truck is called a semi, what would we call one twice as big? These are not questions that keep me up at night. This is only a paragraph of prose that yearns to grow up to be a poem.